It does seem to be only the few "tried and tested" routes that consistently have competition, i.e. 16/94/50/404. I would say certain other routes had benefited from competition while it existed, e.g. Diamond used to run a, from memory, well loaded 51E service to Scott Arms at a fairly regular frequency, but unfortunately it didn't last, and they used to do well on the 9 from memory as well.
I do feel that operators wanting to set themselves up on a corridor should look more at establishing a niche of some sort, e.g. Central buses on the 28 should run the full route to Scott Arms, as only half the NX buses do that, or when Diamond ran the 64 to Bromsgrove (shame that one didn't last). Preparing to be shot down for this particular one, but I would also say like on the Bristol Rd, with the 61/63 and the 98, I would personally see that as a kind of competition of sorts, as I do know of some people living in Selly Oak who prefer to catch the 98 than the 61/63 into the city center, it might have something to do with the 98 route being a bit nicer than all the traffic on the Bristol Road and the smoother ride (and the buses not being Tridents)
I like what Claribels have done if I'm honest, they've established themselves on some key routes in east birmingham that gets them well noticed (and from what I've seen by the loadings, fairly well loved/appreciated) in that one particular area, if they suddenly started up on the 16 or (randomly) the 24 I doubt they would be as successful
I do feel that operators wanting to set themselves up on a corridor should look more at establishing a niche of some sort, e.g. Central buses on the 28 should run the full route to Scott Arms, as only half the NX buses do that, or when Diamond ran the 64 to Bromsgrove (shame that one didn't last). Preparing to be shot down for this particular one, but I would also say like on the Bristol Rd, with the 61/63 and the 98, I would personally see that as a kind of competition of sorts, as I do know of some people living in Selly Oak who prefer to catch the 98 than the 61/63 into the city center, it might have something to do with the 98 route being a bit nicer than all the traffic on the Bristol Road and the smoother ride (and the buses not being Tridents)
I like what Claribels have done if I'm honest, they've established themselves on some key routes in east birmingham that gets them well noticed (and from what I've seen by the loadings, fairly well loved/appreciated) in that one particular area, if they suddenly started up on the 16 or (randomly) the 24 I doubt they would be as successful