News:

Please do have a browse through the forums or use the Search functionality before posting a new topic - chances are there is already a discussion underway on that subject, or your question has already been answered previously!

Main Menu

Bus breakdown experiences

Started by Stu, July 07, 2012, 07:35:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

MSU2008

#3150
Quote from: frostjay974 on May 06, 2025, 03:29:36 PMPN certainly don't seem to be having a very good day today!
Certainly they've had a few break downs today and some other technical issues with buses meaning they've had to swap although 4759 has been taken back to garage and 2098 which broke down this morning has come back out.

Norris

I saw a dennis trident tonight at Northfield lockwood road broken down. I thought they were reliable buses.

D

#3152

Quote from: Norris on May 06, 2025, 09:24:27 PMI saw a dennis trident tonight at Northfield lockwood road broken down. I thought they were reliable buses.
Yes, 4613. Air leak from the doors. 
Lokale Linien:
27: Frankley nach Yardley Wood über Bournville.
61: Birmingham nach Frankley über Bristol Straße.
(zu fuß in 20 minuten) 49: Rubery Great Park nach Bahnhof Solihull.

Jay71

Quote from: Norris on May 06, 2025, 09:24:27 PMI saw a dennis trident tonight at Northfield lockwood road broken down. I thought they were reliable buses.
I thought they were reliable buses. Lol
Do you know how old the bus is?

Wumpty

#3154
Quote from: Jay71 on May 06, 2025, 11:29:04 PMI thought they were reliable buses. Lol
Do you know how old the bus is?
Considerably more reliable than some of the posts from "enthusiasts" on this forum!

Regardless of how old the bus is, it's mechanical and electrical and breakdowns happen with any bus (see PN thread from yesterday), so unsure what point the original poster @Norris was trying to make.

I understand from other posts that it  suffered an air leak.
Autofare 3 - the ticket that laughs in the face of contactless!

don

Quote from: Wumpty on Yesterday at 08:28:45 AMConsiderably more reliable than some of the posts from "enthusiasts" on this forum!

Regardless of how old the bus is, it's mechanical and electrical and breakdowns happen with any bus (see PN thread from yesterday), so unsure what point the original poster @Norris was trying to make.

I understand from other posts that it  suffered an air leak.
I would imagine, reading between the lines, the poster was commenting on the basis that a 21 year old vehicle in all day service is more likely to break down than one less long in the tooth!! Do any other large operators run such elderly vehicles? They certainly don't in London, with which I'm more acquainted, where the franchising arrangements result in newer vehicle age profiles.

I travelled on several of these elderly NXWM Tridents and Geminis recently and they certainly, from a passenger viewpoint are quite comfortable and acceptable. 
Bustimes.org - armchair bus chasing at its best
wmbusphotos.com - armchair bus spotting and news at its best.

Wumpty

Quote from: don on Yesterday at 08:56:08 AMI would imagine, reading between the lines, the poster was commenting on the basis that a 21 year old vehicle in all day service is more likely to break down than one less long in the tooth!! Do any other large operators run such elderly vehicles? They certainly don't in London, with which I'm more acquainted, where the franchising arrangements result in newer vehicle age profiles.

I travelled on several of these elderly NXWM Tridents and Geminis recently and they certainly, from a passenger viewpoint are quite comfortable and acceptable.
Which is exactly the point - the average punter won't be interested in its age as long as it gets them from A to B in relative comfort and on time. As I eluded to yesterday, some much younger buses at PN yesterday broke down for various reasons.

Appreciate that not many large operators may run buses of a similar vintage, but that is testament to the talented NX engineering teams - in a similar vain to the longevity of Fleetlines and Metrobuses running long into the 21st century.
Autofare 3 - the ticket that laughs in the face of contactless!

don

Quote from: Wumpty on Yesterday at 08:59:09 AMWhich is exactly the point - the average punter won't be interested in its age as long as it gets them from A to B in relative comfort and on time. As I eluded to yesterday, some much younger buses at PN yesterday broke down for various reasons.

Appreciate that not many large operators may run buses of a similar vintage, but that is testament to the talented NX engineering teams - in a similar vain to the longevity of Fleetlines and Metrobuses running long into the 21st century.
Yes I agree regarding the engineering. However the real question is whether they're more likely to break down than a newer vehicle and without 'inside info' we are unable to know. 

However, I think it's wrong to assume people don't notice the age of vehicles - I have observed people commenting about this in a negative way - it's even made the press on occasion (more usually about coaches - which is one reason that operators began using personalised, ageless number plates on such vehicles). 
Bustimes.org - armchair bus chasing at its best
wmbusphotos.com - armchair bus spotting and news at its best.

Jay71

Quote from: Wumpty on Yesterday at 08:59:09 AMWhich is exactly the point - the average punter won't be interested in its age as long as it gets them from A to B in relative comfort and on time. As I eluded to yesterday, some much younger buses at PN yesterday broke down for various reasons.

Appreciate that not many large operators may run buses of a similar vintage, but that is testament to the talented NX engineering teams - in a similar vain to the longevity of Fleetlines and Metrobuses running long into the 21st century.
The Geminis & Tridents are much comfortable than Ominicrap

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk